annoying popup ads and google penalties
Estimated Reading Time: 9 minutes

Google’s Interstitial Popup Penalty: A 2023 Update

Remember those pesky popups that used to annoy us while browsing on our mobile devices? Google sure does! Back in 2016, Google took a stand against what they called “intrusive interstitials” – those annoying popups that blocked us from getting to the good stuff. It was all about making our mobile browsing experience smoother and better.

Before the mobile era, we had new window pop-ups that opened on various websites. And they got excessive. You could easily have 4 or 5 windows open, and then you had pop-unders that opened in the background. They were essentially a separate page with a no-index tag attached to it.

Once mobile platforms became more popular, standalone interstitials really hurt the overall mobile user experience, so the use of a website element such as a modal window or pop-up overlay became the new intrusive interstitial, and Google pretty much penalized anything that affected the main browser window.

Fast Forward to 2023, and Google’s approach has evolved so that it’s now all about balance. They get it – sometimes, we need popups. But now, they want those popups to be helpful, not a hindrance.

TL;DR Summary: The Evolution of Google’s Mobile Interstitial Penalty

  • Google’s mobile interstitial penalty has evolved from penalizing intrusive popups in 2016 to a more nuanced approach in 2023.
  • The focus is on enhancing user experience and rewarding websites that prioritize seamless navigation on mobile devices.
  • Age verification, cookie consent overlays, and non-intrusive interstitials are considered acceptable.
  • SEO ranking factors consider popup timing, relevance, and size, favoring sites with well-implemented, user-friendly popups.
  • Mobile-first indexing emphasizes the need for mobile-friendly designs and user-centric popups.
  • Strategic popup implementations like slide-ins and exit intent popups strike a balance between revenue generation and user satisfaction.
  • The future holds potential for personalized and location-based popups, as Google’s algorithms continue to refine search rankings.

The 2016 Stance: Navigating Popups in the Mobile Era

In 2016, Google had a massive campaign against intrusive interstitials—popups that obstructed the user’s access to the main content.

An entirely new section in Google’s guidelines was added with how Google would react when it comes to displaying pop-ups. The other search engines, for the most part, had no official statement on whether they were a negative impact on rankings. But Google dominated in 2016, so we’re going to focus there!

This move was motivated by the search giant’s commitment to providing mobile users with seamless and informative encounters. The aim was to discourage practices that negatively impacted user satisfaction and organic search traffic.

The introduction of the “mobile interstitial penalty” marked a shift towards rewarding mobile-friendly pages prioritizing user experience. Websites that used interstitials that hindered users’ access to content easily were at risk of losing their positions in search results.

Do Interstitial Popup Windows Hurt SEO?

Ah, the big question: do those interstitial popup windows really mess up a website’s SEO efforts? The answer is a bit nuanced. 

Back in 2016, Google cracked down on these popups that seemed more interested in hogging our attention than giving us what we came for. And yes, if your website was guilty of hosting intrusive interstitials, your search rankings could take a hit.

But hang on, it’s not all doom and gloom. Google has realized that not all interstitials are a problem

Google's Interstitial Popup Penalty

It’s 2023 and the traditional pop-up has changed. Google isn’t out to punish all popups. It’s more about giving us, the users, a guided view of the web. If your popups play nice, like age verification or cookie consent, you might not need to worry as much. In fact, Google has learned to tell the good popups from the bad ones.

The traditional full-screen takeover popups and those that appear right as we land on a page – Google’s not a fan. They can still hurt your SEO efforts. Why? Because they disrupt our flow and make us scramble for that tiny ‘X’ to close them. And Google’s all about making our journey seamless.

It’s all about balance. Pop-Ups can generate revenue and help increase leads, but they need to be smartly implemented. There’s a lot more to traffic conversion and content marketing than a banner that says, “Here, buy my stuff!

So, if you’re worried about your SEO, remember: not all popups are bad, but the bad ones can still cost you. It’s all about delivering a smooth user experience while still achieving your website’s goals.

The Transition 2023: A Balanced Pop-Up Window Approach

Moving forward in time to today, the landscape has evolved. Google has fine-tuned its approach, understanding that while popups can sometimes be necessary for legitimate reasons, their implementation must be thoughtful and user-centric.

Refining Interstitials for a Smoother Experience

The penalty is no longer a blanket action against all popups. Instead, Google now distinguishes between different types of interstitials. Age verification interstitials, cookie consent overlays, and login windows on private content are generally considered “non-intrusive interstitials,” and are perfectly acceptable. In some cases, they’re actually legally required. However, the threshold is ensuring that these interstitials are non-intrusive and not detrimental to the user experience.

Putting Users First: The User Experience Is Prioritized

The crux of Google’s mobile interstitial penalty has always been rooted in promoting a positive user experience. Websites that provide valuable content while minimizing interruptions with popups are more likely to earn higher organic search rankings. Today, the focus has shifted from simply penalizing popups to rewarding sites that go above and beyond to deliver seamless navigation and meaningful engagement.

Google’s algorithms now take into account a more nuanced understanding of how popups are employed on websites. While the sheer volume of popups remains a consideration, other factors such as timing, relevance, and size have gained prominence. This change ensures that websites with well-implemented popups that enhance the user experience can still maintain or even improve their SEO rankings.

Embracing a Mobile-Centric Approach for Seamless Browsing

With the growing dominance of mobile devices, Google’s mobile-first indexing is a cornerstone of its search engine software. The penalty for intrusive interstitials is particularly significant for mobile users, as their screen real estate is limited. Websites that cater to mobile users by offering responsive designs, non-intrusive popups, and quick loading times have the potential to be more successful in the mobile search landscape.

Striking a balance between Revenue Generation and User Engagement

Recognizing that popups can be a legitimate revenue generation tool for websites, Google has evolved its stance on the issue. While traditional popups and overlays can potentially hinder user experience, strategic implementations such as slide-ins, notification bars, and exit intent popups are viewed more favorably. This allows websites to balance their revenue goals with providing an enjoyable browsing experience.

Promotional Marketing, Coupon Pop-Ups, and Page Content

There is a delicate balance between promotional marketing and user experience. We all love a good deal, but there’s a difference between a dialogue notice regarding a coupon and the dreaded banner ads.

When implemented properly, a discount coupon notice can generate revenue that otherwise would have been left on the table. From a marketing strategy, having a window open during an exit intent – when a user navigates to close the browser window – is a great incentive to capture what could have been a lost sale.

You can also have interstitials triggered based on how long someone has been on the site, or how many pages they have been to. This is very common with live chat boxes or a way to restrict access to the site unless a user provides their email address. The restricted access method is very common with real estate type websites.

Well-executed interstitial pop-ups can actually enhance the user experience when they’re timed right and don’t overwhelm the screen. Language selection pop-ups are common on international websites, but you should restrict these so the user receives this on their first page load of a session.

At the heart of everything is the page content, and while most websites operate under the same browser window, others will force a new window to open. Opening a new window can often signal a new session, and it can also cause problems in your analytics with regards to tracking the traffic source.

Google’s always been focused on connecting us with valuable information, and that hasn’t changed. You are free to use pop-ups and restrict them to mobile browsers or a specific mobile experience, but remember why the user is there – content. If a popup covers up the content the user came for, that’s a problem. Google’s algorithms are smart enough to know when pop-ups are hiding the good stuff. So, when it comes to page content, the rule is simple: let us get what we want without making us jump through hoops.

The Future Outlook: What to Expect

As Google’s algorithms continue to refine and adapt, the mobile interstitial penalty will remain a key consideration for WordPress websites and other platforms aiming to enhance their online visibility. The search engine’s commitment to rewarding positive user experiences and mobile-friendly designs will continue to shape future SEO strategies.

Technology-Driven Solutions: With advancements in technology, websites have access to innovative ways of delivering content without compromising user experience. Modal windows that provide information without obstructing the main content, along with intelligent targeting based on user behavior, are expected to become more prevalent.

Personalization and Localization: Google’s emphasis on delivering tailored experiences might lead to the emergence of personalized interstitials based on user preferences or location. This could enhance user engagement while maintaining the balance between user experience and information dissemination.

Continued Algorithm Refinements: Google’s algorithms are known for their continuous updates. Future algorithm changes may further refine the criteria for assessing popups, considering factors like user engagement and interaction with interstitials. Staying up-to-date with these changes will be crucial for webmasters aiming to maintain and improve their search rankings.

My Final Thoughts On Mobile Pages

Google’s journey with the mobile interstitial penalty is like that friend who went from being a pop-up party crasher to a savvy event planner. By 2023, this penalty had transformed from a strict enforcer to a wise mentor, teaching webmasters the art of engaging content without firehosing a user with “buy me” propaganda.

As the digital space gets crazier, businesses need to keep up with the rhythm of change. It’s time to break the mold and craft SEO strategies that are more about wowing your audience than mindless clicks.

If you have a WordPress website and are stuck with what to do regarding WordPress SEO, contact us for SEO help. We have been performing SEO consulting, creating SEO friendly websites, and auditing keywords for over a decade. We understand what Google values as quality content.

Need Help with SEO? Contact Big Red SEO!
Share this post
Check Out These Other Articles
Organic Search Traffic vs Google Ads
Conor Treacy

4 Reasons Organic Search Traffic Is The Best Choice Over Paid Ads

When it comes to marketing your business online, investing your time and energy in improving your organic SEO efforts can help you to save money while driving more organic search traffic to your website. Bringing traffic to your website using paid advertising and social media websites can be effective; however, it will not be cheap. Another downside is that these platforms seem to change the rules on what you can and can’t do for exposure more frequently.

Read More »